
Curriculum: The Never Ending Dialogue Dateline: Warner Springs Guest, Ranch. September 10, 1967 The Charter Curriculum Committee is well into its third day now. And although, twenty-five years later, the bare-bones phrasing of the written record makes no mention of fatigue or frayed nerves, the tone of the minutes is increasingly terse. A typical excerpt comes from the discussion on the course "Introduction to Clinical Medicine": 'Dr. Simon suggested that the number of hours should be 120 to 150. Dr. Orloff felt that the figures were far too low and should be between 300 and 350. Dr. Livingston asked whether clinical lab experience was in ICM and Dr. Orloff said that it was. Dr. Simon disagreed and said that lab diagnosis was handled elsewhere. Dr. Braunwald said that he didn't see how a student could be accepted into the third year without knowing how to do a sed rate or a blood count. Dr. Liebow pointed out that the students would not be doing blood counts on patients...' And so it went, as twenty-five physician-educators, each one with unique and definite ideas on the best way to mold a competent physician, grappled with the learning gestalt known as curriculum. No easy task, for these physicians had taken as their basic premise that the new school would serve as a forum for fresh ideas and techniques in medical education. They began with the most basic questions: How long should it take? Four years, three years, or ten? How about a thesis; does it whet critical inquiry, or is it meaningless tedium to the student who itches only to transplant a heart? Will electives create Renaissance doctors, or merely entangle the pursuit of medicine? Should summers be open for independent scientific endeavor, or will a student bound for June study at the Sorbonne cheat - be discovered swooping down the slopes of the Matterhorn? And what about grades: A through F, or Pass/Fail? Dean Clifford Grobstein knew what they were all in for, and in his charge to the participants he pleaded with them not to "get hung up on details, intriguing or emotion-generating though they be... Curriculum is merely the faculty's way of organizing its efforts to maximize the effectiveness of its interaction with students..." As for a "complete syllabus of what every medical student should grasp," Dr. Grobstein knew better. That was not agreed upon twenty-five years ago in the desert, it has not been agreed upon since, and it will doubtless receive no pure consensus in the future. And although the faculty-chosen Committee on Educational Policy (CEP) and its two subcommittees, the Core Curriculum Committee (CCC) and the Electives Committee (EC), reach conclusions (because they have to), the dialogue between status quo and change is sustained - as befits 400 chiefs schooled in the best Socratic traditions. But the unavoidable fact that the subjects in the core curriculum you will encounter during your time here - which represents the minimum that every medical student must learn - have changed little testifies to the committees' essential nature. They are conservators, and will alter the core only after exhaustive study, debate, study, and then more debate. Insertion of new core necessarily means the death of other elements, a pronouncement made only after the sincerest scrutiny.
|
| Curriculum: The Never Ending Dialogue |
The CoreYou will find cogent descriptions of the core curriculum on later pages, but the following notes may give you a notion of how and why the various courses are taught. But first a clarifier. There are two modes of presentation of core: block and strip courses. To understand the difference, first think of a blockhouse of knowledge, a more or less discrete structure of ideas and facts, complete with foundation and roof, that represents the essentials of a given topic. You will live here for a while, then move on.For strip course, think strip-farming, a method of cultivation which sows knowledge over a given span of space and time, and which reaps its educational bounty little by little. The strip courses are ongoing inquiries that build through the semesters, along with the student's insight. Follow us, then, through the towns and fields of a country called
Core. Cell Biology and BiochemistryCBB is the first block course you will see, and it is the first
building block in your professional career. It epitomizes the
wisdom that a firm grounding in biological and biochemical mechanisms
is crucial to the truly competent physician. The "readings" portion
of CBB puts a small number of students together with a distinguished
faculty member/biochemist for a dynamic exchange on the material
just studied. If you have never experienced an undergraduate biochemical
laboratory, you are strongly urged to enroll in the elective laboratory
portion. From 1968 to the present, CBB has immersed the student
in molecular and cellular principles, traversing the intact organism,
down through the cell to the molecule, then back out again. Then
you will look at the clinical correlates of these biologies. Social and Behavioral SciencesWhat do you say to patients who are ill or injured, highly suggestion-prone, overly helpful, ambiguous, and paranoid? How can you best ease the fright of these patients who have brought their suffering to you along with a variety of expectations, myths, stereotypes, and - perhaps most importantly - untapped emotions? During your first quarter at UCSD, you will begin to answer these questions through participation in exercises and small group discussions in the Doctor/Patient Relationship course, the first of four parts of the strip SBS sequence. SBS is a course which looks at the patient as a person, with all that implies, but also as a unique "biopsychosocial matrix," with a history and a future. SBS will, in its many modes of delivery, stress (1) that the most
fluid and evanescent of intangibles - the doctor/patient relationship
- to a large extent shapes the patient's suffering and its amelioration;
(2) that illness is disharmony at any of three levels - biological,
psychological, or social - which in turn disrupts the other two
levels; (3) that developmental stages are a good way to look at
the changing dynamics in a patient, be it childhood, adolescence,
or aging; and (4) that the milieu in which the 'healing arrangement'
takes place - the myths and symbols of the culture, the way money
is organized and distributed, how the society views its deviant
members, death, and sex - incorporates interested parties who
refuse to stay out in the waiting room. They must be examined,
and accounted for. Introduction to Clinical MedicineThis is a five-quarter course beginning in January of Year I. By the end of the first year, students will have learned to recognize symptoms and signs of disease and will have mastered a basic screening physical examination. Year II emphasizes basic skills of physicianship, including history taking, physical examination, complete patient write-ups, and oral case presentations. ICM provides a living lab for students to nurture the art of interviewing
and diagnosing common disease syndromes in closely supervised
bedside work, demonstrations, lectures and conferences. Organ PhysiologyThis is a demanding course because the subject matter is completely new to most medical students. The course deals in turn with the lung, heart, kidney, and gastrointestinal systems and runs parallel with the pharmacology course. Students can get considerable help from the new edition of the physiology textbook that is largely written by faculty teaching the organ physiology course. In addition, Dr. Nora Laiken, who is in charge of tutoring, is ready with supplementary notes and a helping hand for those who need further clarification. |
Back to Top |
|
Principles of PharmacologyPrinciples of Pharmacology is a course given in the fall, winter, and spring quarters of the first year. In the fall quarter, students learn the fundamentals of pharmacology and the autonomic nervous system. In the winter quarter with concepts in physiology, students learn the cardiovascular system, and smooth muscle, along with the principles of drug disposition. These are taught simultaneously with cardiovascular, renal, and gastrointestinal physiology. In the spring quarter, the pharmacology of central nervous system active drugs is taught parallel with basic neurology.Endocrinology-Reproduction-MetabolismThe touchstone of this course is the multi-faceted endocrine system
and the hormones by which it regulates growth, sexual development,
reproduction, reactions to stress, and many key metabolic processes.
Metabolic disorders and poor diet patterns account for a great
deal of disease in the U.S. This course covers obesity, diabetes
mellitus, and hypercholesterolemia among the more prevalent such
diseases. In addition to reproductive endocrinology, the course
deals with basic physiology of reproduction, including conception,
contraception, aspects of sexuality, and the physiology of pregnancy.
Basic NeurologyThe brain is the center for our thinking and feeling. This course
looks at everything from the fine structure of individual neurons
to the complex anatomy and physiology of the human nervous system.
Throughout the course, there is an ongoing consideration of the
brain's higher functions (emotions, behavior) and of the disorders
that interfere with the nervous system's normal performance (clinical
neurology). To provide instruction of this scope, the course is
managed by both basic and clinical neuroscientists. Human AnatomyAnatomy at UCSD's School of Medicine differs in several ways from the course of the same name traditionally found in America's med schools. First, it comes after students have already learned about bodily functions, after OP. Therefore, it can be taught as functional, practical anatomy, not only morphology. It is taught by a team of anatomists, surgeons, and radiologists in a setting that gives heightened emphasis to radiology. "It's important to use all the modern imaging methods to get a feeling for how the organs and tissues show up in those media, and to learn their relationships," says an involved faculty member. Anatomy is also one of the most popular of all courses here, perhaps
because of the close personal contact between instructors and
students in the small group seminars and the laboratory. HistologyTaught in conjunction with anatomy, this course is designed to
teach the structural basis of normal and abnormal function at
cellular and tissue levels. Emphasis is placed on microscopic
study conducted in small laboratory groups under close faculty
supervision. Epidemiology/BiostatisticsThis course describes uses and limitations of biostatistical techniques and of epidemiology and population versus patient data. It includes terminology, study design and analysis, measures of risk, causality, screening, and current knowledge about the epidemiology of selected diseases/conditions and medical interventions. Case studies are used to emphasize understanding of the principles behind statistical tests and understanding statistical jargon used in the medical literature.
Human DiseaseThis course provides the transition from the basic science curriculum to the clinical setting. It is designed to teach the principles of human disease and constitutes an integration of such separate subjects as pathology, pathophysiology, microbiology, and medical therapeutics. The beginning phase of the course focuses on the general principles of human disease, and subsequently, the course covers diseases of organ systems. Pathology and pathophysiology deal with causes, mechanisms, structure,
and dynamics of diseases. Medical therapeutics addresses principles
and some specifics of pharmacologic interventions that are helpful
in altering the disease process. Microbiology, which rests on
the assumption that living agents of disease are best studied
in relation to reactions of the host, is closely coordinated with
the same organ system approach. HematologyThis course, taught in the second year fall quarter mini-block,
consists primarily of small group discussions and laboratories
centered around clinical cases. You will cover the physiology
and pathophysiology of blood cells and blood cell-forming organs.
Laboratory MedicineWhat are the general principles of laboratory data interpretation? This course covers a basic introduction to these principles and to the systematic use of laboratory tests in evaluating common clinical conditions.ElectivesMany medical schools do not provide students the opportunity to
choose any part of their curriculum in the first two years, but
this is definitely not the case at UCSD. Time for electives has
been an integral part of the schedule since the school was founded.
Throughout the pre-clinical curriculum, two afternoons each week
are completely free and may be used for elective courses. The
elective curriculum is as unstructured as the core curriculum
is structured; myriad opportunities exist to explore areas ranging
from the most basic to the cutting edge of science and technology.
Clinical preceptorships* are plentiful and popular elective choices.
Many students participate in elective community outreach efforts
such as DOC (Doctors Ought to Care), teaching middle and high
school students about AIDS, alcohol and drugs, or, the UCSD student
run free clinic. Others use their elective experiences to learn
to speak Spanish or to learn to take a medical history in Mandarin
Chinese. There are electives about the politics of medicine, alternative
medicine, and the history of medicine. A course in anatomic drawing
might also be appealing, but if none of the formal offerings pique
students' interest, students may approach any faculty member and
design a reading or laboratory course. UCSD students appreciate
the freedom and breadth of the elective curriculum, and participation
in these courses has led to many memorable experiences. For a description of the Independent Study Project, which technically
also is part of the elective curriculum, please see the Independent
Study Page. *In which students work with practicing physicians in specialties like family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, otolaryngology and cardiothoracic surgery. |
Back to Top |